Tuesday, June 1, 2010

Boycotts work two ways.

My beloved wife and I had planned on going to Anaheim this October and spend a fun weekend at Disneyland.  I've been wanting to see the "Haunted House on Holiday" exhibition for the last couple of years and we finally seemed to able to arrange things so that we could go this fall.

Well, all of a sudden, California cities started making a fuss about Arizona's anti-illegal immigration enforcement laws, also known as "SB 1070", also known as "Arizona Safe Neighborhoods and Law Enforcement Act".  Cities like Los Angeles, San Diego and Berkeley (OK, Berkeley isn't a surprise, really) have indicated that they will boycott contracts with Arizona.

Clearly, they've not actually read the law (even though the total number of changes to existing Arizona state statutory laws account for only about 16 pages or reading).  Clearly, they've not yet seen that the law can only be enforced as part of a "contact by law enforcement officials" for other reasons and that questions can only be asked about immigration status if "reasonable suspicion" arises as part of that lawful contact.  They've also clearly not read the even more strongly worded amendment that specifically prohibits the use of race in evaluating "reasonable suspicion". 

OK, California. Have it your own way. But although your contracts with us are important to us, I know that tourism from out of state visitors is also important to you.  So let me point out a few things:
  1. Rasmussen polls:
    1. 53% in Pennsylvania favor passing legislation similar to AZ SB1070 in their state.
    2. 57% in Texas support passing legislation similar to AZ SB1070 in their state.
    3. 68% oppose boycotts of Arizona over SB1070.
    4. 55% nationally favor immigration law similar to AZ SB1070 in their state.
  2. Pew Research Center
    1. Broad approval for New Arizona Immigration Law
      1. 73% approve requiring people to produce documents verifying status. (86% of Republicans, 65% of Democrats, 75% of Independents)
      2. 67% approve allowing police to detain anyone unable to verify status.
      3. 59% approve the general provisions of SB1070.
  3. Gallup Poll
    1. Among those who have heard of the law, 51% favor and 39% oppose it.
  4. MSNBC/Telemundo
    1. 61% favor AZ SB1070, although only 31% of Latinos favored it.
So... if you look at these results, it's pretty simple: Nearly 2/3 of the nation disagrees with the city council rulings for San Diego, Los Angeles and Berkely (amongst others). And just as California wants to flex it's financial muscle (oh... wait... what financial muscle? Isn't CA like 21 billion in the hole?),  so can we who support AZ SB1070.

You remember that California vacation I alluded to earlier? Well, we're going to Jackson Hole, Wyoming instead.

No comments: